Henry’s Toasties Recipe

Henry’s Toasties recipe gives you the perfect choice of a sweet and savoury recipe both from episode 2 (season 1) of The Fabulous Baker Brothers.

Choose between classic melted cheese and ham or sweet and sticky peanut butter, chocolate and banana.

Here at Hobbs House Bakery we love Henry’s Toasties as we can’t think of a better way to use our bread, then sandwiching it full of oozing ingredients, either melting cheese or dripping chocolate.

If you love Henry’s Toasties recipe why not try our ultimate Sourdough Cheese Toastie recipe.

To make an authentic Hobbs House Bakery toastie with Henry’s Toasties recipe buy one of our bread boxes online and you can try our different loaves to create the perfect toastie.

Serves 2


  • 4 slices white bread

  • 2 slices juicy ham

  • 2 slices Gruyère cheese

  • Big dollop of crunchy peanut butter

  • 3 chunks chocolate

  • ½ banana, sliced

  • Plenty of melted butter

  • Sprinkle of sugar


  1. For the savoury toastie, sandwich the cheese and ham between two slices of your bread. Brush both sides with some melted butter then stick it in the toastie machine and toast it until golden and bubbling.

  2. For the sweet and sticky toastie, layer the peanut butter, banana and chocolate on your bread. Sandwich with another slice and brush all over with more melted butter. Scatter with sugar and toast until the sandwiches are golden.